i missed the first but watched tonites and thought it was great, tis a pity there is only a few, im hoping they make more

 

anyone watch it

i watched the first one

 

took a while to get my head round it, but by the end i'd really enjoyed it

 

going to watch the second in a bit

It was very good. Cumberbatch is a brilliant actor - Freeman was pretty good too.

 

The only thing that upset me was that they changed "a 3 pipe problem" - meaning that he would have had to take enough time to smoke 3 pipes to work out a problem - to a "3 nicotine patch problem". Bloody anti-smoking nazi writers! How dare they mess with great literary characters.

ive only seen the 1st one so far and I thought it was fantastic. i have to admit I'm a bit of a SH purist (Ive read the short stories twice and really enjoy watching Jeremy Brett's interpretation).

 

I thought they brought the new SH up to date really well while keeping some traditional elements in there. both Cumberbatch and Freeman play their characters superbly, but its a shame that Benedict looks a bit too 'weird'. :x:

 

^ ditto re the 3-patch problem, nice touch but yep too 'modern'

>>Jeremy Brett's interpretation

 

The definitive portrayal, imho :)

i think jeremy brett was the best ever sherlock

 

i even liked downey as sherlock in the new film and am hoping they make a second film

tonite at 9pm, last one

cant believe they only did 3 :headvswal

there has to be more, they cant leave it at that lol

They only done 3 because it blows chunks